BreakPoint with Charles Colson

Commentary #021028 - 10/28/2002

Of Science and Religion: What Really Got Galileo into Trouble

Tomorrow night on PBS, NOVA will present a program that can stimulate some valuable discussion and reading. If Christians handle it wisely, it might give us a chance to correct the popular misconception that Galileo, the seventeenth-century astronomer, was the victim of religious suppression of science. This is important, because critics have always used the Galileo story to unfairly paint the Church as anti-science.

Allegedly, theologians in Galileo's day were unwilling to consider any evidence that contradicted Ptolemy's theory that the earth was the center of the universe. Copernicus's and Galileo's hypothesis that the earth revolved around the Sun, the story goes, was brutally suppressed. But history is not all that simple.

Dr. Owen Gingerich, who appears on tomorrow's program, has devoted much of his life to studying Copernicus and Galileo. As research professor of Astronomy and of the History of Science at Harvard and senior astronomer emeritus at Smithsonian Astrophysical Observatory, he has spent years studying questions like this. He's convinced the primary issue between Galileo and the Church wasn't whether the earth revolved around the Sun -- the heliocentric theory. Instead it was "a turf battle over who had the keys to the truth, one that was especially exacerbated at that time because of the Catholic battle with the Protestants over the way to interpret Scripture." The primary issue was not heliocentrism, but "how literally Scripture should be interpreted."

Gingerich reports, "About two-thirds of the copies [of Galileo] in Italy were censored and essentially none elsewhere . . . [T]he rest of the world saw that exercise as a local Italian imbroglio, and they were having none of it."

The truth is that Pope Urban VIII had a strong interest in science. Although he accepted the view that Earth was the center of the universe, he authorized Galileo to write a book to explain the alternatives. If Galileo had simply presented his view, everything would have been fine.

Instead Galileo presented the competing views as a drama for three actors. The character espousing Pope Urban's view was named Simplicius. Gingerich observed, "Galileo has arranged the dialogue to make Simplicius's words sound like the dying gasp of a man whose arguments had been drowned in a deluge of contradicting facts . . . The choice of words, and the context in which they were set, made Urban look like a complete fool." Urban was a powerful enemy, and Galileo was put on trial. But he wasn't convicted of heresy, as everybody thinks. Galileo was convicted of teaching heliocentrism, when he had been forbidden to do so. It was a case of insubordination.

We really don't know whether the NOVA documentary will have an anti-Christian bias and present the old myth that the Christian Church was -- and is -- opposed to good science. But in light of some of the things Dr. Gingerich has said in the past, you may want to tune in. Keep in mind it probably has some spin -- the media can't resist it. But if Gingerich's views are offered, it could help offset the reductionist "science or religion" interpretation often associated with the Galileo controversy.

Christians need to have the facts and correct the legends. NOVA, on Tuesday night, just might give us an opportunity to do that.

Printer-Friendly Version http://www.breakpoint.org/Breakpoint/ChannelRoot/FeaturesGroup/BreakPoin tCommentaries/Of+Science+and+Religion.htm?PF=1

FURTHER READING & INFORMATION "Galileo's Battle for the Heavens," NOVA, Public Broadcasting Corporation, to be aired October 29, 2002 at 8:00 P.M. http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/galileo Check local listings as dates and times may vary. http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/schedule-local.html

Eric Charles Barrett and David Fisher, SCIENTISTS WHO BELIEVE: 21 TELL THEIR OWN STORIES (Moody, 1984). https://http://www.pfmonline.net/str_donation.taf?Site=BP_Item&Item_Code=BKSWB

Owen Gingerich, "The Galileo Affair in Contemporary Perspective," SCIENTIFIC AMERICAN, August 1982. http://www.sciam.com Also reprinted in Owen Gingerich, THE GREAT COPERNICUS CHASE AND OTHER ADVENTURES IN ASTRONOMICAL HISTORY (Cambridge, 1992). http://www.powells.com/cgi-bin/biblio?inkey=62-0521326885-0

Article about Galileo in Isaac Asimov's BIOGRAPHICAL ENCYCLOPEDIA OF SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY, second revised edition (Doubleday, 1982), 100-105. http://www.booksfactory.com/writers/asimov.htm

David Fisher, "A Lifelong Quest: Tracking Copernicus," (biographical sketch of Owen Gingerich), Newsletter of the American Scientific Affiliation, September/October 2002, 5 http://www.asa3.org/ASA/newsletter/sepoct02.pdf (requires free Adobe Acrobat Reader). http://www.adobe.com

Owen Gingerich, "The Censorship of Copernicus's 'De Revolutionibus . . . ,'" JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN SCIENTIFIC AFFILIATION 33, no. 1 (March 1981): 58-60. http://www.asa3.org/ASA/PSCF.html

Charles E. Hummel, THE GALILEO CONNECTION (InterVarsity, 1985), chaps. 1-5. http://www.parable.com/breakpoint/item_087784500X.htm

Dan Falk, "Harvard Professor Owen Gingerich Sees Religious Roots of Astronomy," Space.com, 22 September 2000. http://www.space.com/colleges/college_gingerich_profile_000921.html

Owen Gingerich, "Is the Cosmos All There Is?", REFLECTIONS, Center of Theological Inquiry, 2002. http://www.ctinquiry.org/publications/gingerich.htm

Charles Colson and Nancy Pearcey, DEVELOPING A CHRISTIAN WORLDVIEW OF SCIENCE AND RELIGION (Tyndale, 1999). https://http://www.pfmonline.net/str_donation.taf?Site=BP_Item&Item_Code=BKSAE

NEW ON BREAKPOINT It takes a Superdad to raise a Superson. Smallville, now in its second season, offers perhaps the best example of a good father currently on television. Read "Superdad" by guest writer Alex Wainer. http://www.breakpoint.org/Breakpoint/ChannelRoot/FeaturesGroup/OnlineFea tures/Superdad.htm

CONFERENCES AND EVENTS An exciting three-day BreakPoint worldview conference is coming up, featuring Chuck Colson, Michael Novak, Jack Kemp, and others! "Christians in the Marketplace" will be held at the beautiful Cheyenne Mountain Resort and Conference Center in Colorado Springs April 4-6, 2003. Call 1-888-672-0007 for more information. http://www.breakpoint.org/Breakpoint/ChannelRoot/WelcomeGroup/Wilberforc eConferences/Christians+in+the+Marketplace.htm

"FACE THE FUTURE: Beyond Bio-Nanotech, Cybernetics, and the Future of the Human Race," a 2-day conference sponsored by the Council for Biotechnology Policy and the Center for Bioethics and Culture, will take place September 19-20, 2003, in Oakland, CA. Register early for the best rate! http://www.breakpoint.org/Breakpoint/ChannelRoot/WelcomeGroup/Wilberforc eConferences/Face+the+Future.htm

RECOMMENDED RESOURCES In SCIENTISTS WHO BELIEVE, authors Eric Charles Barrett and David Fisher

show how, for many scientists, their Christian faith is a product of their scientific studies-and their further studies and insights are a product of their faith. https://http://www.pfmonline.net/str_donation.taf?Site=BP_Item&Item_Code=BKSWB

For more books, CDs, videos, and other materials visit the BreakPoint Resource Center. http://www.pfmonline.net/products.taf?Site=BPT&Category=BPT

BreakPoint to Go! Get BreakPoint delivered to your handheld device or mobile phone. http://www.breakpoint.org/Breakpoint/ChannelRoot/FeaturesGroup/BreakPoin tCommentaries/BreakPoint+to+Go%21.htm

ABOUT BREAKPOINT http://www.breakpoint.org/Breakpoint/ChannelRoot/WelcomeGroup/AboutBreak Point/

REPRINT INFORMATION http://www.breakpoint.org/Breakpoint/ChannelRoot/WelcomeGroup/FAQ/BreakP oint+FAQ.htm#reprint

BREAKPOINT STAFF http://www.breakpoint.org/Breakpoint/ChannelRoot/WelcomeGroup/AboutBreak Point/The+Wilberforce+Forum+Team.html#staff